Rails Are What You Make of Them

Going Off Script

eso 2014-02-17 13-54-30-89 There was a topic yesterday that started with Tobold’s post and wound up in a G+ comment stream.  While I believe Tobold’s comments about on rails gaming were initially about a certain game that is still under NDA with a space theme…  it eventually wound its way to Elder Scrolls Online.  To which I added the information I posted yesterday on my own blog, about the fact that the majority of quests are skippable, and that there are a very few that actually need to be completed to move to the next area.  But the root of the problem here I think is that after a decade of playing themeparks…  we have gotten extremely good at seeing rails.  Moreso I think we are so trained to stay inside of the lines that we are afraid to break out of the little protective cage the themeparks have built for us.

For the longest time I fought the “quest to level” construct and then over time I managed to get extremely good at mindlessly grinding them.  There was a time when I could take a character from 1-85 in less than seven days in World of Warcraft.  The problem is… this is a thing I do to level quickly, and not something that comes instinctual.  I am constantly deviating from the path, and poking my head into places I shouldn’t be.  If I have 10% to go to a level, my instincts are not to grind some quests, but instead to go kill some really high level mobs.  You can blame Everquest for this type of “go kill things” upbringing, and I am still happiest when mindlessly slaughtering bad guys.  So when I am out questing, skipping that bad guy for the sake of speed is not usually a thing that ever enters into my mind.

So when I was plunked down on Stros M’Kai in the Daggerfall Covenant for the very first time… I willfully and gleefully ignored the quests that were given to me.  I wandered off and explored the island, gathered some crafting bits, found lots of treasure chests and leveled happily oblivious to the fact that there was a rail.  Sure eventually I reined myself in and did a few quests, but the vast majority of that first couple hour play through was aimlessly exploring.  If I found a cave I poked my head in to see what was there.  The little voice in the back of our head that says “don’t go there yet, you will have a quest for it later” is something that we end up doing to ourselves.

Rails Are What You Make of Them

eso 2014-02-17 13-36-59-84 For the most part I would agree with Tobold’s assessment of that space game, but since so many people love it I continue trying to give it a second and a third and a fourth chance.  I went through this same thing with Guild Wars 2, I kept trying to see what people liked about it… because I honestly didn’t understand it.  Over the weekend I maybe landed at how to enjoy it.  Once I finished the tutorial, I went completely off the rails, wandering around aimlessly killing lots and lots of things and getting nifty bits in the process.  That mode of play made the game enjoyable for me.  Quests are a really good way to level, and I think they also do an excellent job of telling the story.  However something we have forgotten along the way is that they are mostly optional.

We can blame World of Warcraft for this to be honest, but not in the way you might think.  WoW brought quests out into the open, where they had always been something for insiders before.  In Everquest you went around /hail-ing every single mob you encountered because maybe just maybe they might have a quest for you.  In Dark Age of Camelot, you did the same thing trying to locate the “Kill Task” quest giver for a specific area.  City of Heroes gave you specific contacts you needed to talk to that acted as a hub for running future missions.  Finally World of Warcraft gave us the now ubiquitous golden exclamation point… taking complete all of the subtlety out of it.  Still… even in WoW it was not until Burning Crusade that I really started to lean on quests as the crutch that they are.  I got a good number of my levels by going off the beaten path and looking for neat things out in the world.

To some extent it is also the fault of games that have stopped giving us things to find just over the next ridge.  There should always be things just out of the way for us to go looking for, because this act reminds us that there is another way to play the game than just mindless questing.  This self directed fun is crucial, and is what ends up making a game stay fresh.  I tend to cycle through two modes of gameplay…  aimless wandering and mindelss questing.  I find both to be really enjoyable when I am in the right frame of mind.  I think this is why I can return to WoW all these times and still be happy with what it is.  That said I am constantly going off script in that game as well.  There are so many nooks and crannies that often lead to treasure or at least interesting things to kill.  Basically… these rails that we keep seeing, are something we’ve allowed ourselves to see.

Dungeons of Belgrade

BelgradeKeep_Update With all the talk of ESO lately, I am still very much playing Landmark on a daily basis.  Last night I got in and worked on Belgrade Keep for a bit.  I tweaked the exterior a bit adding supports to the first balcony and then building out an entirely new balcony from the top of the castle.  Additionally I added some more of my custom columns to the corners of the ramparts to tie the visual theme together, as well as adding some to the ground floor to mark the entrances to the ramp leading up to the keep and the entrance to the crafting undercroft.  I thought I was nearing a point where I needed to simply grind out the various accoutrements to decorate the keep.  I was completely wrong however.

I decided that Belgrade keep needed a proper dungeon, so I spent the majority of the night watching episodes of Arrow on Netflix and hollowing out the basement by hand with the remove tool.  One of the things I have noticed that removing large blocks of material with the select tool often ends up leaving weird fragments.  So I tend to do it manually simply because I like the results better.  After having spent hundreds of hours hollowing out tunnels branch mining for diamonds in Minecraft… I find I have an affinity for that sort of work.  The plan is to divide up the sub basement into cells, maybe with a torture area…  but that all depends on how creative I am.  I am curious if I have enough room for a second sub basement to be honest, because I can seemingly dig down further.

My Father the Builder

I really need to sit down and brainstorm out the rest of the month, because when I am not staring at a blank page I am full of ideas with factoids.  However when I sit down to write at 6 am, my mind is mush and devoid of any good ideas.  So today’s factoid is going to be a little odd, be warned.  I am not a terribly handy person, as in I am not a manly man builder type.  I can watch a youtube video and figure out most things, but I have a bit of a mental block about things that are mechanical.  In part I think it is because my father is so damned amazing at it.  I realize he grew up in an era when if you didn’t fix it yourself it stayed broken, and my grandfather was the king of tinkerers.  For me however, since I spent most of my childhood sick… I just simply was not exposed to it…  apart from getting to be the loyal “flashlight holder”.

At a young age I think I told myself I couldn’t do this.  There are things that are well in the realm of my mastery.  You give me a few boxes, scissors, magic markers and tape… and I will build for you a GI-Joe base that will make you weep.  However you dump a heap of mechanical bits on the table and I cannot see the same possibilities.  Growing up with a machinist for a father was a really interesting and awesome thing.  When I broke a wheel off one of my hot wheels… he would take it away to a magical land where it would come back with a shiny new wheel better than the previous.  He would take it over to work and machine out of scrap aluminum a wheel, then carefully wrap it in electrical tape for traction…finally carefully attaching it back to my hot wheel.  My father could make magic happen.

I just wish I appreciated it more at the time.  When Star Wars was all the rage, I wanted nothing more than the Death Star play set.  I did not grow up with a lot of money, so spending $100 on a cheap plastic and cardboard play set was really out of the question.  That Christmas instead my dad hand crafted me a Death Star that was far cooler than anything store bought ever could have been.  I am still not sure exactly how he built it, but he had some long screw running down the back of the unit with a crank up top. and a machined elevator that rode up and down on the screw.  So that I could crank my action figures up and down between the floors.  Now I appreciate just how ingenious it was, but probably at the time I wished I had the “real thing”.

As my father is getting older, I am starting to have to figure these things out on my own.  I know at some point he won’t be there to call for advice.  Someday I will have to learn the lessons he had to learn.  I admit it scares me, to think about a world where a master builder like my father doesn’t exist.  I don’t think he really knows how in awe of his abilities I am, and how much I wish I had his natural intuition for how things should go together.  I should really remedy that, but my father is a lot like me, and not really great at saying these sorts of things in person.  There are times I think that maybe he DID pass on his legacy to me, but that it just changed over the years.  I am good at computers and hacking around with software to get it to work the way I want it to work.  Then when I can’t find whatever it is that I am looking for, I know that I can crack open Visual Studio and build it myself.  So maybe just maybe I have some of that same magic too.

7 thoughts on “Rails Are What You Make of Them

  1. As for guidance, it’s really the players that lead this charge. As Chris said, players seem to want to fall into comfortable patterns rather than blazing new trails. The current market is mostly Achievers, with us Explorers always feeling left behind. Explorers are just a much smaller group size-wise.

    As for your factoid, it’s fascinating because I’m the same way. I would happily create buildings out of cardboard boxes, but I wasn’t the fix-it guy for mechanical things. I’m also a programmer, but I tend to be much more creatively-focused than engineer-focused like other programmers are.
    Brian ‘Psychochild’ Green recently posted..Moving on, looking for new opportunitiesMy Profile

  2. I don’t mind a bit of direction with the main story line, but I would like to see more discover-able side quests. Wandering around the overland stumbling upon quest NPCs or finding artifacts or ruins that the main story wont lead you to.

  3. I’d really like to see MMOs turn back in the direction of more interaction and less theme park, simply because they do the theme park thing badly. If I’m ultimately playing a single player RPG, no MMO will do it as well as a true single player RPG like The Witcher or Mass Effect. Making the game online and throwing 5000 other people in the way doesn’t improve anything when you’re supposed to do everything alone.

    The whole point of the genre (and where it shines) is when you start tackling stuff with other people, and interesting things happen. That’s where the strengths are. Making a MMO that tries to give you a full solo experience is ignoring what the genre is good at and instead playing to it’s greatest weakness.

    It’s hard to justify paying a monthly fee for something I can get done better in 50 other games that are on sale on Steam.

    I don’t really understand Landmark (maybe you should do an introduction blog post for it!), but from what you’ve shown of it, that might be going in a direction I’d find more interesting.

    (All that said I did have fun with a nameless space themed game. For what it’s trying to be, it’s well executed.)

  4. I love your father story. My dad was a carpenter and now a home inspector. Even tho I never became a carpenter I’m great mechanically like him. After all, I am a aircraft mechanic. It comes extremely easy to me too.

    Great post makes me think of my dad. I need to call him today
    Scarybooster recently posted..Drinking Bacon Flavored PissMy Profile

  5. “To some extent it is also the fault of games that have stopped giving us things to find just over the next ridge. ”

    The games may have lit the fire, but MMOers keep spraying on the gasoline. No one is interested in failure, so we have a never ending parade of guides that tell you how you should play. People expect other players to study these guides and commit them to memory or else they can’t be part of the group. Everything has to be by the numbers, and that lies squarely and solely at the feet of the player base.

    When many people move from themepark to sandbox, they can’t grasp the concept of freedom of imagination. It’s daunting, not having even the slightest bit of content to at least propel them in a direction. Like EVE. ALWAYS like EVE. People know that in EVE you can join a corp and do epic PvP, but for a new player, getting to that point is like staring up Mt Olympus, with it’s peak shrouded in mist. You know it’s there, but you can’t accurately fathom the work it’ll take to even get started.

    TESO seems like a good mix of choice. You can play it on rails by only doing the quests and if that’s your bag, you’ll get a lot out of it. If you want to run around and explore, it seems like the kind of game that allows that as well. It’ll be a good transition game for people used to themeparks, but who are also curious about sandbox because there’s the familiar fallback of structure there should folks get confused.

    The only ruining speck on the horizon that this game will be ripe for guides and walkthroughs to satisfy people who want the exploration feel, but who don’t actually want to “get lost” in the process : /
    Chris recently posted..The [Redacted] OnlineMy Profile

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: