You Waited Too Long

I realize I talked a little bit about this yesterday, but I am pretty happy I went ahead and made the move to Gamepad.club. So far thanks to the amount of work that Gaz poured into making sure we had good federation, the experience has largely been uninterrupted. I still have access to the various hashtags that I had been following and am still seeing a similar volume of traffic coming from them. That is one of the sometimes gotchas from moving to a smaller instance, is that oftentimes hashtags don’t work quite as well. Generally speaking, the federation of a given instance is dictated by who the members of that instance follow. The more users on an instance, by nature the deeper the federation and the more successful things like hashtags become. I follow 814 accounts and as a result, my joining an instance adds those 814 connections. You can quickly imagine that mesh being extended for each person that joins a given instance.

Relays come into play to try and solve this problem. They end up granting servers access to everything being federated within a specific group, and by joining multiple relay networks you can artificially expand the reach of your server. So while you effectively live in a much smaller bubble, the local instance… you can still see topics actively being propagated amongst all of the instance servers in that network. When Gaz was setting up Gamepad.club he joined enough networks to create this effective mesh of 4000 or so servers that we were connected to. So while we have a fairly quiet local feed, the federated feed feels pretty much like it did when I was on Mstdn.social or Masto.ai.

So you are probably asking yourself if everything is effectively the same… why did I bother moving? The truth is there is no requirement to really move servers ever. Stux is great and the instances that he is responsible for mstdn.social, mastodon.coffee, and masto.ai are also pretty great. There is a thing that tends to happen when folks become active on the Fediverse. They discover the local feed and for a while it is exciting and new. The problem with a local feed on a giant server is that eventually it stops being exciting. Eventually, it becomes this dumping ground of too much chatter going on at once to ever hope to follow any of it. On a smaller server, the local feed often feels like going to the corner store and seeing a bunch of people you only sorta meet and are as we call it in rural america… “on waving terms” with. I wanted that back, and while Gamepad.club is pretty quiet and largely made up of people that I already follow, I am certain at some point in the future it will be that place for me.

Migration is also just part of life in the fediverse. It is largely considered a “feature” rather than a bug and it means that even thought right now Mastodon.social the flagship instance is being impacted by a round of denial of service attacks, the rest of the network continues to truck along fine largely oblivious. Legitimately had Gargon not said anything about it and it was boosted into my feed… I never would have known because it hasn’t been impacting any of the instances I have been involved with this week. I’ve migrated so many times at this point that while I end up putting it off usually… it is also a fairly painless occurrence and given how often it happens for various folks… it is just accepted at normal. I’ve talked about my long history of moves, but just to throw it all out there here is my history on Mastodon.

• Mastodon.cloud – signed up for this not even having a clue that instances were unique things because like so many Twitter transplants I assumed it was a monolithic service.
• Elekk.xyz – when I realized different instances had different purposes I joined the only “gaming” instance at that time.
• Nineties.cafe – my friend Liore started an instance on Masto.host and I popped over because it was something led by someone I actually knew.
• Elekk.xyz – back to Elekk when Nineties.cafe was shuttered for various sundry reasons.
• MMORPG.social – migrated over to a new MMORPG-focused instance because why the heck not?
• Elekk.xyz – back to Elekk when MMORPG.social was shuttered for various sundry reasons.
• Mstdn.social – I joined this server because Elekk was under new management and had defederated from a bunch of instances that my friends were on, making it impossible to communicate with them anymore. Stux seemed like a nice admin.
• Masto.ai – Mstdn.social was overwhelmed with new sign-ups, and Masto.ai was created as an overflow instance. A bunch of us longer-term Mstdn.social folks migrated to try and help ease the load.
• Gamepad.club – My friend Gaz creates an instance and I once again throw my lot in with a smaller instance because while I am perfectly fine with Masto.ai I missed the smaller instance feel.

So in my five years on the Fediverse, I have migrated nine times, and each time had its own reason. The thing is… I could have stayed on Mastodon.cloud and never moved. Some people are going to want to plant their flag and never leave. Others like me, are going to flit around the fediverse between different environments at will. Truth be told… ALL of my accounts other than the two defunct instances are still active and I could migrate to ANY of them at will again in the future.

The scary thing at the moment is that those who failed to get off Twitter when the rest of us migrated… might have waited too long. On February 9th the Muskrat is shutting off free access to the Twitter API. As a pre-emptive strike, he shuttered access to the accounts that were being used to run all of the third-party Twitter clients. Most recently his gaze has turned to the API accounts being used to create helpful migration tools like Movetodon that allowed you to connect your Twitter account, and then allow you to follow those same people on Mastodon. As of this week, those accounts seem to have been flagged as violating Twitter rules and policies. So the easy migration period is over, from this point forward you are on your own.

Yesterday in the real world, my team spent the day gutting Twitter from our public-facing websites. Previously we had used the free Twitter API to cache copies of all of the tweets sent from our official accounts. We had them appearing in the sidebar, and the cached copies kept us from running into issues with connectivity and causing that UI element to “wig out”. However even our very meager access pattern would end up costing us over a thousand dollars a month. I figure soon over the coming weeks you are going to find all of the ways that you used to integrate Twitter with applications you enjoyed, similarly shuttering that functionality. That means more than likely all of those video game integrations like the one I have used the most to get screenshots off my Switch and PS4/PS5, will be shut down and non-functional.

Twitter didn’t die in the fiery cataclysm that some of us thought that it might. However, it still seems to be dying a slow rotting cancerous death as it loses functionality and as a result cultural importance. I popped over the other day to change out the mastodon information in my profile and found myself depressed at how different it feels. Sure there are folks who are still using it, but the quantity of activity is a pale comparison to what it once was. I miss a lot of people, for example, I miss seeing Liani’s posts filling up my feed, but I can’t support what is happening over there especially when there is a better option. February 9th is going to be a significant moment in this saga because it will be interesting to see how devoid of Twitter content a lot of sites suddenly end up being. I just have to hope that my paths will cross with the folks stranded on the sinking ship that is Twitter because the easy life rafts have already departed and they might have to dog paddle away on a door.

Anyways long twisting post later… Gamepad.club is great and I am glad I made my move. It is small and quiet, but sometimes I need that in life. If you don’t have a good mastodon home already, then I welcome you to check it out.